Please disable your Ad Blocker to better interact with this website.

CDC Had its Own “Protocol Breach”: Why Should We Trust Them on Ebola?


It’s official. Ebola has spread to another person in the United States after a nurse at a local Dallas, Texas hospital contracted the disease after caring for a Liberian man who was infected with the Ebola virus. The Liberian patient later died of the disease.

image source: wikipedia

Dr. Thomas R. Frieden (image source: wikipedia)

Shortly after it was announced that the nurse had contracted the virus, Dr. Thomas Frieden, the Director of the Center for Disease Control and Prevention wasted no time in advising the media that there had been a “protocol breach.”

In other words, Frieden was implying that the nurse had somehow failed to take all necessary precautions to ensure that Ebola was controlled.

Frieden went on to state that there would be a full inquiry into how the breach occurred and added that 48 other people who may have had contact were now being closely monitored.

While some health experts have criticized Frieden for using the nurse as a “scapegoat,” it’s not surprising to see the CDC beginning to point fingers at the “mistakes” of others.

“You don’t scapegoat and blame when you have a disease outbreak,” Bonnie Castillo of National Nurses United said. “We have a system failure. That is what we have to correct.”

While Castillo is correct about not placing blame on others, her statement is of little comfort to those that may have relied on past CDC statements that boasted of U.S. preparedness in dealing with Ebola.

Now, it appears that the CDC may be ramping up its damage control measures before a possible Ebola outbreak occurs due to mishandling of the disease by hospitals throughout the U.S., who are not as well-trained or equipped as the CDC would have the American public believe.

Certainly, CDC would not want to be held responsible for a possible pandemic should it occur in the near future.

Also, Frieden’s statement about the breach of protocol implies that all U.S. hospitals have been adequately prepared by CDC or other training and the appropriate equipment is in place to properly curtail the spread of Ebola.

Generally, speaking the CDC does not get involved in telling hospitals how to run their operations but sometimes takes the initiative when it believes that the hospital has run into difficulties. This occurred recently when CDC felt that hospitals were not handling their electronic health records properly.

Is it time for CDC to takeover other aspects of hospital operations, specifically those aimed at Ebola training and containment at all U.S. hospitals?

Before you answer that, let’s take a look back and see how well CDC handles infectious and deadly diseases at its own laboratories.

CDC admitted to mishandling five incidents in their own facilities when they improperly sent anthrax, botulism and a strain of bird flu to their government laboratories within the past decade.

At the time, Frieden said, “These events should never have happened.” The American people “may be wondering whether we’re doing what we need to be doing to keep them safe and to keep our workers safe.”

It turned out that there had been a problem at CDC’s main Bioterrorism Rapid Response and Advanced Technology anthrax lab. Some of the problems involved the use of unapproved sterilization techniques.

No organization should be more prepared than the CDC in handling infectious and deadly diseases and potential biological threats in an appropriate and safe manner.

image source:

image source:

If the CDC can’t get it right 100 percent of the time then how are hospitals that are possibly without the same kind of training and necessary equipment to handle such diseases expected to get it right?

CDC’s record for handling deadly pathogens appears to be a tarnished one that should prevent it from quickly speaking out to condemn others.

Clearly, we can’t rely on the CDC or our hospitals to prevent the spread of Ebola in all cases.

Therefore, the best course of action that can be taken by the U.S. to prevent the disease from infecting anymore people in the U.S. is to temporarily halt all travel into the U.S. from West Africa.

At the very least, a mandatory quarantine should be ordered for all those entering the U.S. from West African countries.

No other solution will guarantee that Ebola will not impact another life in the U.S.

CDC appears to be downplaying the problems associated with the readiness of our hospitals to contain and control this disease.

This stance essentially amounts to playing Russian roulette with the health and well-being of the American public when they are ensured that all is under control.

One look at CDC’s own track record shows that mistakes are possible and probable. When an infectious disease is involved, a mistake can be deadly.

The only reasons that lives are currently being impacted is because travel is allowed into the U.S. from West Africa.

How long will the American public remain silent about this national security threat that continues to be invited onto our shores daily by an administration that won’t even consider a temporary ban on travel?

Demand from your President and your Congress that they act now to protect lives in the U.S. by implementing a temporary ban on travel from West Africa. A refusal to act is a refusal to uphold the responsibility of the office to which they were elected.

While some believe that neither Congress nor the President will act, we cannot rebuff the idea until we petition them to perform their duties.

We must not take any option off the table at this point because the health and safety of the U.S. is plainly at stake.

Related content:




Join the conversation!

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.

About Author

Susan Calloway Knowles

Susan Calloway Knowles, is a licensed Psychotherapist and former practicing Family Law Attorney, Author, Guest Speaker on Conservative Internet Radio, and a political/cultural Blogger. Susan is also an avid investigative researcher having honed her skills in the legal profession. Susan’s website,, covers articles she has written on an array of topics, including governmental interference of parental and children’s rights, the U.S. Constitution, military and veterans’ issues, issues pertaining to California from the viewpoint of a conservative living in a Blue State, and hot topics pertaining to the Obama Administration’s policies, including immigration policies. You can also find her on Twitter at @SusanKnowles. Susan’s book, a political fiction, is entitled “Freedom’s Fight: A Call to Remember,” and is available on Amazon.

Send this to a friend